Blog · Comparisons

TrendSpider vs Wickform: automated strategy tests or bar-by-bar practice?

TrendSpider runs your rules over years of data in seconds. Wickform makes you trade the chart one bar at a time. They answer different questions, and here is how to tell which one you need.

Practice vs live in the Wickform demo journal: rules followed 98% in practice and 85% live, average R +0.51R against +0.33R.
In short
  • TrendSpider is an analysis platform with a no-code strategy tester: define the rules and it runs them over historical data for you.
  • Wickform is a bar-replay backtester with a journal built in: you trade the past by hand, and it records and reviews every trade.
  • If your strategy can be written as exact rules, TrendSpider tests it faster. If it relies on your judgement, you need to practise it, and that's what Wickform is for.

What TrendSpider is

TrendSpider is a charting and market-analysis platform built around automation. It detects trendlines and chart patterns for you, overlays several timeframes on one chart, scans the market for setups, and sends alerts or runs bots when conditions are met. It covers a wide range of markets, including stocks, ETFs, options, forex and crypto.

Its strategy tester is point-and-click: you choose entry and exit conditions, and it reports the results with a trade list and statistics such as win rate, profit factor and maximum drawdown. It also has a chart replay mode for manual practice. TrendSpider's plans sit at the higher end of trading tools; see their pricing page for current tiers.

What Wickform is

Wickform does one job in depth: lets you trade the past as if it were live, and turns every trade into something you can learn from. You pick a market and a date, the future is hidden, and you place orders with stops, targets, partial exits, breakeven and trailing stops.

Each trade is journaled with screenshots, a playbook, rule checks and a grade. The analytics break results down by session, hour, weekday and setup, show how far each trade ran for and against you, and re-run your entries with 36 different stop and target combinations.

Two kinds of backtesting

Systematic: the rules decide

You define the strategy so precisely that a computer can trade it: "buy when the 20 EMA crosses the 50 and RSI is under 60, stop at the last swing low." The tester runs it across years of data in seconds. It's fast and objective, but it only works if your strategy can be written that precisely, and it tells you nothing about whether you can execute it.

Discretionary: you decide

Many strategies depend on reading context: was that sweep clean, is the higher timeframe with you, does this level matter today? Those can't be coded easily. The way to test them is to trade them: replay the chart, take the trades you'd really take, and record everything. It's slower, but it tests the strategy and your execution together. Its weak spot is hindsight, which is why Wickform hides the date in its blind drills.

Side by side

TrendSpiderWickform
Testing styleRules run automaticallyYou trade each bar by hand
Who makes the callThe rulesYou, with the rules as a checklist
SpeedYears of trades in secondsDozens of trades per session
What it measuresThe rules' edgeYour edge with those rules, execution included
MarketsStocks, ETFs, options, forex, cryptoAny market you import bars for
Also doesAutomated trendlines, patterns, scanners, alerts, botsHigher-timeframe candles, auto key levels, sweep alerts
JournalNot a trading journalBuilt in: screenshots, playbooks, grades, tags, missed trades
Review toolsBacktest statistics and trade listBreakdowns by session and setup, MAE / MFE, exit optimizer
Prop-firm practiceNoChallenge mode (Pro)
CostHigher tiers; see their pricing pageFree plan; paid plans from $8 a month, or $64 a year

TrendSpider details checked on 1 Nov 2026 from public reviews and product pages. Features and prices change, so check their site before you decide.

Which one should you use?

Choose TrendSpider if

  • Your strategy is fully rule-based, or you want to explore indicator ideas quickly.
  • You trade stocks or options and want scanners and alerts across the market.
  • You want to automate entries with bots.

Choose Wickform if

  • Your strategy depends on reading the chart: levels, sweeps, sessions, context.
  • You want to build the habit of executing a plan, not just validate one.
  • You want every practice trade journaled and reviewed without a second tool.
  • You're new and want a low-cost way to get real reps before risking money.

Using both

They fit together well. Use a systematic tester to find out whether the core idea has any edge at all. If it does, move it into Wickform and trade it bar by bar, so you learn what it feels like to take those trades, where you hesitate, and which sessions suit you.

Key takeaways
  • TrendSpider tests rules. Wickform tests you trading the rules.
  • Coded strategies belong in a strategy tester. Discretionary strategies need replay and a journal.
  • The two approaches complement each other: validate the idea, then practise the execution.

FAQ

Can Wickform run my rules automatically?

No. Wickform is for manual, bar-by-bar backtesting. The closest it gets is the exit optimizer, which re-runs your own entries with different stops and targets.

Is manual backtesting less reliable than automated testing?

Not if you guard against hindsight and use realistic fills. It measures something different: how a person trades the strategy. Hide the date with a blind drill and journal every trade, and the results are honest.

Does TrendSpider have a trading journal?

It isn't designed as one. It records backtest trades, but not the playbooks, grades, screenshots and notes a journal keeps.

Start today

Your next strategy deserves a fair test.